WEBVTT

00:00:06.200 --> 00:00:07.640
Welcome in San Diego.

00:00:07.640 --> 00:00:11.920
It's Jade Hindman on this episode of KPBS Midday Edition.

00:00:11.960 --> 00:00:16.960
The City of San Diego votes to end its contract with FLoC will have all the details.

00:00:17.000 --> 00:00:19.480
This is KPBS Midday Edition.

00:00:19.520 --> 00:00:22.160
Connecting our communities through conversation.

00:00:30.000 --> 00:00:36.040
Last night , the San Diego City Council unanimously voted to end the use of flock cameras in San Diego.

00:00:36.120 --> 00:00:40.760
The decision comes after several council members changed their stances on FLoC.

00:00:40.800 --> 00:00:45.000
As concerns grow around privacy and abuse by law enforcement.

00:00:45.040 --> 00:00:49.400
City Council member Sean Rivera said trust has been broken.

00:00:49.680 --> 00:01:00.220
I think that's the thing that I find most dangerous about this , and it's the false confidence that the technology produces and a tool that treats people as guilty until proven innocent doesn't make anyone safer.

00:01:00.380 --> 00:01:05.740
The city council also voted to stop the use of smart street light cameras , a separate program.

00:01:05.780 --> 00:01:10.140
Joining me to break this all down for us is Andrew Bowen , Metro reporter for KPBS.

00:01:10.140 --> 00:01:14.220
And also Jacob McKinney , enterprise reporter for Voice of San Diego.

00:01:14.260 --> 00:01:15.780
Andrew Jacob , welcome.

00:01:15.820 --> 00:01:16.380
Hi , Jade.

00:01:16.460 --> 00:01:16.940
Hey , Jade.

00:01:16.940 --> 00:01:17.620
Thanks for having us.

00:01:17.660 --> 00:01:18.620
Glad to have you both.

00:01:18.620 --> 00:01:23.220
So , Andrew , to understand this vote , we have to retrace how we got here.

00:01:23.260 --> 00:01:28.780
Recent efforts to ban Alpers at the City Council failed as recently as June.

00:01:28.780 --> 00:01:29.220
So?

00:01:29.220 --> 00:01:30.540
So what's changed?

00:01:30.580 --> 00:01:38.580
Well , one thing I think that's changed is that there's just been a lot more national attention on this technology and on this company flock safety in particular.

00:01:39.180 --> 00:01:44.260
There were cases of very clear and egregious misuse in other cities.

00:01:44.260 --> 00:01:48.940
And then , you know , like a cop stalking an ex-girlfriend , for example.

00:01:48.940 --> 00:01:56.380
And then in recent months in San Diego , we found that there are actually cases here that also may have crossed a line.

00:01:56.420 --> 00:02:06.920
So two lawsuits were filed , one by two men who say that they were falsely identified by an ALP search and wrongfully arrested.

00:02:06.920 --> 00:02:16.960
And then another one , another lawsuit in which a man says that he there was a misidentification due to an ALP search and he was shot by police.

00:02:16.960 --> 00:02:34.120
And so , you know , clear examples of , you know , if these are proven in court , that of of the technology really not living up to what , you know , the standards and the certainty that I think the police tried to suggest they would provide.

00:02:34.120 --> 00:02:47.520
And then I think the final nail in the coffin was actually news reported by Jacob here about the police using these cameras in an internal affairs investigation against a police officer.

00:02:47.560 --> 00:02:49.640
Well , Jacob , tell me more about that case.

00:02:49.800 --> 00:02:52.520
Yeah , it was a fascinating story for a couple of reasons.

00:02:52.520 --> 00:02:59.790
One , I think it showed that even folks within the police department weren't all on the same page about how the technology was being used.

00:02:59.990 --> 00:03:13.190
At its most basic , the story kind of showed that SPD has been using data from its ALP network , its network of 500 automated license plate reader cameras using FLoC technology to surveil officers.

00:03:13.190 --> 00:03:15.150
In the course of internal investigations.

00:03:15.150 --> 00:03:18.630
They'd confirmed to me that they'd done this at least six times.

00:03:18.750 --> 00:03:29.550
But in this particular instance , they were surveilling an officer who had been accused of having sex with a woman that he had met while responding to a domestic violence claim.

00:03:29.550 --> 00:03:32.350
This is a woman who was a victim of domestic violence.

00:03:32.350 --> 00:03:36.550
He took her number from his field notes and contacted her while on duty.

00:03:36.630 --> 00:03:55.050
The investigation did ultimately determine that he'd had sex with her , but in the course of that investigation , the officers the internal investigators used its network of LPR cameras to track the cops car and the car of the domestic violence victim , with whom he was expected of having an affair.

00:03:55.450 --> 00:03:59.090
This set off a whole lot of alarm bells for a lot of people.

00:03:59.370 --> 00:04:04.810
I think a lot of people on the outside viewed this as a huge misuse of the technology.

00:04:04.810 --> 00:04:13.370
An innocent woman who was suspected of no crime was surveilled using this technology , but inside the department , it set off even more alarm bells for them.

00:04:13.410 --> 00:04:20.210
This felt like a clear overstep of what this technology would be used for , and they felt that they had not been warned.

00:04:20.250 --> 00:04:27.810
They had not been let in on the fact that the department and internal internal investigators would be using these in administrative investigations.

00:04:28.050 --> 00:04:37.290
There's been a big back and forth between Police Chief Scott Wall and the union president and the union itself about whether or not this has actually been agreed to.

00:04:37.330 --> 00:04:43.690
And the information from that case led City Council member Raul Campo to change his stance on Alpers.

00:04:43.690 --> 00:04:45.610
Why was that significant?

00:04:46.050 --> 00:04:49.370
Well , I think because he was a sixth city council member.

00:04:49.370 --> 00:04:54.750
And in order to rescind the use policy of Alper.

00:04:54.790 --> 00:05:10.870
So this is the technically the action that the council took last night was to revoke the police's permission to use this surveillance technology , and the council could have done that with five votes , and then the mayor could have vetoed that action in order to keep the cameras in use.

00:05:10.910 --> 00:05:16.670
Campo was the sixth city council member to publicly declare he no longer supported this technology.

00:05:16.670 --> 00:05:25.190
And so that made clear , I think , to the mayor that , you know , even if he were to veto it , the council could then go back and override his veto.

00:05:25.230 --> 00:05:38.590
So , you know , public opinion was just kind of on the side of getting rid of this technology and that six city council vote , I think , or at least the position , the public position of a six city council member , um , really made a big difference.

00:05:38.590 --> 00:05:42.270
And I mean , several city council members suddenly changed their stance on FLoC.

00:05:42.270 --> 00:05:48.150
Do you think it's an indication they're listening to constituents here , or is there some political calculus going on?

00:05:48.430 --> 00:05:49.710
Those might be the same thing.

00:05:49.750 --> 00:05:55.530
I mean , I think , you know , when you're if you're listening to constituents , you are making a political calculus.

00:05:55.890 --> 00:06:06.290
Uh , but yeah , I mean , it is interesting , you know , there there were a lot of people in public comment yesterday who thanked specifically the council members who have been against this technology from the start.

00:06:06.330 --> 00:06:09.210
And , you know , give them credit.

00:06:09.290 --> 00:06:24.610
But I think every , you know , all the opponents of this technology also appreciated that when public opinion , there's just this groundswell of opposition to this , these cameras that , you know , that that actually has an impact on , on a position of a council member.

00:06:24.650 --> 00:06:34.930
Yeah , I think over the past year , really , but over the past couple of months in particular , it's really hard to overstate just how toxic Alpers and FLoC in particular as a company.

00:06:34.970 --> 00:06:42.890
Again , FLoC is just one company in this realm of companies that offer software that allows , you know , for license plate readers to , to work.

00:06:43.090 --> 00:06:50.360
Um , it has become it has gone completely underwater among people on all sides of the political spectrum.

00:06:50.720 --> 00:06:58.960
And I think that was an indication to council members that this was just not a political position that they would be able to sustain if they wanted to have a further career.

00:06:59.600 --> 00:07:13.040
I think that there was one really interesting case that exemplified this , and it was actually in the D-2 election between Democrat Nicole Crosby and Republican turned independent Richard Bailey.

00:07:13.160 --> 00:07:22.960
During that election , Crosby had long been an opponent of FLoC , had on the campaign trail , said that she wanted to rescind this use policy , get FLoC out of San Diego.

00:07:23.320 --> 00:07:36.080
But during the campaign , we saw mailers sent out by a supporter of Bailey that tried to paint Crosby as , quote , San Diego's FLoC candidate , despite the fact that she was very much against this.

00:07:36.080 --> 00:07:42.080
And it shows to me that campaigns really understood how kind of powerful of a cudgel.

00:07:42.120 --> 00:07:52.340
This support for FLoC was somebody that somebody would spend tens of thousands of dollars mailing completely misleading mailers out to the voters of district two.

00:07:52.340 --> 00:07:58.820
I think really shows that regardless of where you are , people are not ready to accept these things into their neighborhoods.

00:07:58.820 --> 00:07:59.500
So.

00:07:59.540 --> 00:08:00.220
Oh , go ahead , Andrew.

00:08:00.260 --> 00:08:08.220
I was just going to say , I think , you know , another thing that changed is that the opposition kind of did cross political lines.

00:08:08.220 --> 00:08:14.820
So , you know , you have a libertarian minded conservative , let's say , who sees this as big brother surveilling you.

00:08:14.860 --> 00:08:17.220
You know , a big , big government , big police.

00:08:17.660 --> 00:08:20.380
And yeah , I mean , just nationally.

00:08:20.420 --> 00:08:29.220
I think one thing that makes FLoC unique in the sort of constellation of all these different companies that can provide Alper technology is it is a centralized database.

00:08:29.220 --> 00:08:35.940
And so , you know , you could have somebody in one state searching the database and getting a hit in another state.

00:08:35.980 --> 00:08:40.660
Now San Diego says that that was not allowed.

00:08:40.900 --> 00:08:51.960
They initially were making this database available to federal agencies and out of state agencies , and then the state attorney general had to step in and say , that's not allowed under state law.

00:08:51.960 --> 00:08:54.280
And so they they changed the settings , basically.

00:08:54.280 --> 00:09:03.880
But , you know , I think that there was a definitely some conservative opposition to this technology that swung the needle a bit more.

00:09:03.920 --> 00:09:07.760
And FLoC isn't the only company that that runs this type of technology.

00:09:07.800 --> 00:09:08.480
They are not.

00:09:08.480 --> 00:09:14.760
And actually San Diego's contract was with a company called ubiquity , and flock was a subcontractor.

00:09:14.760 --> 00:09:21.120
So but what is significant about the council's vote is that it doesn't specify.

00:09:21.160 --> 00:09:23.480
We're no longer going to work with Flock and City.

00:09:23.480 --> 00:09:26.920
You can maybe find a different company that does a better job with this technology.

00:09:26.960 --> 00:09:36.720
They voted to prohibit the technology's use by the city altogether , so no other company can come and replace flock until the council makes a different choice.

00:09:36.760 --> 00:09:39.120
Yeah , that's a really important note here.

00:09:39.120 --> 00:09:49.980
Just recently , we saw Reno cancel its contract with flock and then immediately switch to a company called axon that essentially has the same exact technology , actually a wider range of services in some ways.

00:09:49.980 --> 00:09:53.340
And there were a lot of activists who were really worried that that would happen here.

00:09:53.380 --> 00:09:53.540
Right?

00:09:53.580 --> 00:09:54.700
That it was flock.

00:09:54.740 --> 00:10:04.260
The name flock had become so toxic , but that Alpa of technology in general , it would be easy to switch over to something that is has a little bit less of a toxic name.

00:10:04.260 --> 00:10:09.780
And so by rescinding the use policy , they , the city council , disallowed the city from doing that.

00:10:09.780 --> 00:10:12.260
And some of those concerns were kind of founded.

00:10:12.260 --> 00:10:21.060
The city has a preexisting relationship with axon , a company which does a whole lot of kind of police technology for body worn cameras , things like that.

00:10:21.060 --> 00:10:30.620
And so the fact that they have foreclosed on that , at least for now , unless they pass a new use policy , I think is really important for the activists that have been in this fight for a long time.

00:10:30.620 --> 00:10:31.900
So what happens now?

00:10:31.940 --> 00:10:33.780
Will the cameras be shut off?

00:10:33.780 --> 00:10:34.380
Removed?

00:10:34.420 --> 00:10:36.060
I mean , what's what's next?

00:10:36.100 --> 00:10:46.560
According to department spokesperson last night's meeting , the cameras will be turned off within 24 hours after the city's vote , and the associated data will be deleted.

00:10:46.560 --> 00:10:51.120
But I think that there is a lot more uncertainty about what happens after that , right?

00:10:51.160 --> 00:11:04.040
These 500 cameras still exist throughout communities all over San Diego , and I think that there will be a longer process to potentially remove those cameras , and that will likely need the mayor's approval in some respect.

00:11:04.200 --> 00:11:09.280
There's a lot of information , some good , some bad floating around out there.

00:11:09.320 --> 00:11:15.280
Uh , something I heard was that the cameras could collect data other than license plates.

00:11:15.320 --> 00:11:16.200
Is that true?

00:11:16.240 --> 00:11:21.480
Well , they can identify a vehicle's make and model and color.

00:11:21.880 --> 00:11:23.920
Um , not always perfectly.

00:11:23.920 --> 00:11:25.040
It was actually kind of funny.

00:11:25.040 --> 00:11:32.800
In last night's meeting , they showed an example of an image of a car , and it said it was a Toyota Forerunner , and I think it was a Corolla.

00:11:32.800 --> 00:11:38.160
So the , the it was far you know , this technology is far from perfect , far from clean.

00:11:38.280 --> 00:11:41.590
Um , but , you know , these cameras are not connected to.

00:11:41.630 --> 00:11:45.030
They're connected to a database , but they're not connected to private devices.

00:11:45.030 --> 00:11:49.390
So if you're walking around with your cell phone , it's not like the cameras are pinging your cell phone or anything.

00:11:49.390 --> 00:11:55.150
It's just they they have , you know , a frame and image , you know , that they can take a picture of.

00:11:55.190 --> 00:12:02.790
The this an AI powered , you know , technology can read a license plate and , you know , put that in the database.

00:12:02.830 --> 00:12:07.230
And there are other capabilities that the San Diego Police Department has said that they do not use.

00:12:07.230 --> 00:12:08.430
For example , flock.

00:12:08.630 --> 00:12:12.030
These cameras can allow police departments to do facial recognition.

00:12:12.070 --> 00:12:12.550
Right.

00:12:12.590 --> 00:12:27.830
This has been something that's really rung a lot of alarm bells across the country because of how difficult it is to really accurately if it's if it's hard for a camera to determine the make and model of a vehicle , you can imagine it's much more difficult to accurately identify a person's face.

00:12:27.830 --> 00:12:30.910
And it's led to a whole lot of misidentifications across the country.

00:12:30.910 --> 00:12:35.030
So there were elements that essentially the police department had not turned on.

00:12:35.030 --> 00:12:39.370
But as you said , Uh , getting into your cell phone is necessarily.

00:12:39.370 --> 00:12:39.690
What?

00:12:39.730 --> 00:12:40.170
Okay.

00:12:40.210 --> 00:12:40.530
All right.

00:12:40.570 --> 00:12:41.370
Good to know.

00:12:41.410 --> 00:12:48.970
Um , Jacob , in late October , when I last spoke with Mayor Todd Gloria , he said he would veto a council vote to remove flock cameras.

00:12:49.010 --> 00:12:51.650
More recently , he said he will not use his veto power.

00:12:51.650 --> 00:12:53.050
So what do you make of that?

00:12:53.090 --> 00:12:55.370
I mean , I think Andrew laid it out really well earlier.

00:12:55.370 --> 00:12:57.450
This was always going to be a numbers game , right?

00:12:57.450 --> 00:13:01.850
When council member Steven Whitburn decided to switch his vote back in October.

00:13:01.890 --> 00:13:06.690
That gave the council its first 5 to 4 majority against these cameras.

00:13:06.730 --> 00:13:07.490
Right.

00:13:07.650 --> 00:13:20.770
But at that moment , they were still trying to figure out where their sixth vote would come from because , as Andrew said , um , the mayor can veto city council votes as long as there are only five people voting on that , right?

00:13:20.810 --> 00:13:22.890
They needed six to override the veto.

00:13:23.330 --> 00:13:27.330
When Council member Cam Pio came out against the cameras last week.

00:13:27.410 --> 00:13:29.770
That gave the the council its sixth vote.

00:13:29.770 --> 00:13:35.490
And interestingly enough , once he got to that sixth vote , other council members started to flip as well.

00:13:35.570 --> 00:13:41.670
Marnie von Hilbert , who was recently elected to Congress , also put out a statement saying that she opposed the cameras.

00:13:41.710 --> 00:13:47.190
I mean , she didn't end up coming to the meeting because she was busy with her Congress stuff , so her vote was not recorded as such.

00:13:47.230 --> 00:13:53.310
And Council member Joe LaCava , who was longtime longtime supporter of the cameras , eventually turned as well.

00:13:53.310 --> 00:14:03.910
So I think ultimately , Mayor Todd Gloria was kind of like taking a check of the of the water temperature and realizing like , oh , it is way too cold for my , my , my Vito to matter at all.

00:14:03.910 --> 00:14:05.870
And that would be an embarrassing position to be in , right?

00:14:05.910 --> 00:14:08.910
To veto something and then to have the council override it.

00:14:08.950 --> 00:14:09.470
Mhm.

00:14:09.590 --> 00:14:16.350
Well , Andrew , notably the council also voted to suspend the use of the city's smart streetlights.

00:14:16.750 --> 00:14:18.670
But that was not a unanimous vote.

00:14:18.710 --> 00:14:20.950
What's the significance of that decision.

00:14:21.470 --> 00:14:26.070
Well so smart streetlights have been in use a lot longer than Alpers have.

00:14:26.070 --> 00:14:29.990
And their history is also quite complicated.

00:14:30.590 --> 00:14:33.150
The the technology is different.

00:14:33.150 --> 00:14:38.730
So the police said they're separate devices , separate cameras , but they're baked into the same contract.

00:14:38.730 --> 00:14:43.050
And so a smart streetlight can record video footage.

00:14:43.090 --> 00:14:47.330
But that footage is not , you know , tied to this AI powered database.

00:14:47.370 --> 00:14:52.290
It has to be manually or visually inspected by a police officer in an investigation.

00:14:52.290 --> 00:15:05.170
So the significance of that technology also being prohibited is that it means the entire contract has to be basically nullified.

00:15:05.170 --> 00:15:16.130
And the police , you know , it's it's just fascinating to see like in in the past ten years , this technology has become quite prevalent in police investigations.

00:15:16.130 --> 00:15:21.250
And really , you know , the police , I think just flew too close to the sun.

00:15:21.250 --> 00:15:25.490
And we're a little too far removed from public opinion about this technology.

00:15:25.650 --> 00:15:33.160
Um , the other thing that's significant about the smart streetlights being also rescinded is that it means there's more savings for the city.

00:15:33.160 --> 00:15:40.440
So if they if the city council had only prohibited Alpers , it would have saved about $750,000 a year.

00:15:40.520 --> 00:15:45.440
Prohibiting both of these technologies , including smart streetlights , saves about 2 million per year.

00:15:45.440 --> 00:15:55.640
So , you know , that was , I think , another thing that probably swayed some council members that the city just had to use its reserves to cover some deficit in the prior fiscal year.

00:15:55.640 --> 00:16:03.320
And they're looking , you know , when when you're in that kind of financial environment , every single spending , you know , every dollar has to be scrutinized.

00:16:03.320 --> 00:16:15.880
And that was something that Mayor Todd Gloria actually said in a statement after the vote is that , you know , in this financial environment , we have to be really , really careful about what we're spending our money on and have to justify every single dollar.

00:16:15.920 --> 00:16:16.200
Yeah.

00:16:16.240 --> 00:16:20.200
Well , and I will say that they're not the technologies are not perfect.

00:16:20.240 --> 00:16:24.320
I my car was broken into right up underneath one of those smart lights.

00:16:24.680 --> 00:16:26.040
Case never solved.

00:16:26.120 --> 00:16:26.440
Yeah.

00:16:26.480 --> 00:16:26.920
Never solved.

00:16:26.920 --> 00:16:27.080
No.

00:16:27.080 --> 00:16:29.080
There are a lot of limits to that technology.

00:16:29.080 --> 00:16:36.100
And , you know , this , I think will mean the police have to go back to doing some real police work and getting out , you know , boots on the ground.

00:16:36.100 --> 00:16:41.020
These these technologies are no longer going to be available to them , at least in the near future.

00:16:41.060 --> 00:16:45.780
I've been speaking with Andrew Bowen , KPBS Metro reporter , and also Jacob McWhinney.

00:16:45.820 --> 00:16:48.260
He's enterprise reporter for Voice of San Diego.

00:16:48.300 --> 00:16:50.500
Andrew Jacob , thank you so very much.

00:16:50.540 --> 00:16:50.700
Yeah.

00:16:50.700 --> 00:16:50.940
Thank you.

00:16:50.980 --> 00:16:51.260
Jade.

00:16:51.260 --> 00:16:52.060
Thanks , Jade.

00:16:59.060 --> 00:17:00.180
That's our show for today.

00:17:00.220 --> 00:17:01.780
I'm your host , Jade Hindman.

00:17:01.780 --> 00:17:03.860
Thanks for tuning in to Midday Edition.

00:17:04.060 --> 00:17:07.060
Be sure to have a great day on purpose , everyone.

